Public engagement is essential to a healthy democracy. It connects citizens to their governments, giving them a stake in decision-making and problem-solving. Yet, many traditional methods of public participation fail to meet community expectations and limit opportunities for real dialogue. When designing public engagement, it’s time to think outside conventional methods and make sure that process design matches the purpose for public engagement, ranging from consultation to empowering citizens to make decisions. We propose strategies that create more inclusive, collaborative, and responsive processes—ultimately leading to greater public trust and more responsive policy outcomes.