To explore how oversight organizations can leverage new approaches, the IBM Center for The Business of Government, in collaboration with the Program Integrity Alliance (PIA), convened an expert roundtable to discuss how government oversight offices can take actions to modernize in the wake of new technology, help to improve agency program outcomes while also ensuring program integrity.
Relevance and Value
Federal oversight organizations have an opportunity to build on their reporting to improve agency performance, strengthen program integrity, and advance mission outcomes. A recent PIA report highlighted that approximately 17,000 recommendations from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) and the Inspectors General (IGs) have not been implemented. Participants discussed several factors that may contribute to this number, including recommendations that are overly prescriptive, outdated, or unclear.
Oversight groups can prioritize recommendations based on their potential to improve program outcomes, rather than focusing on isolated procedural deficiencies. Participants also discussed the value of oversight products beyond traditional reports. GAO, for example, already offers a range of formats including Q&A products, short-form snapshots, Technology Assessments, and testimonies as well as technical assistance, such oral briefings and white papers. Depending on the stakeholder, more targeted products (direct responses to agency inquiries, white papers, or executive summaries) may help agencies translate findings into more accessible and actionable guidance.
Oversight organizations should continue to focus on strategic problem-solving. Adversarial relationships between oversight bodies and the agencies they evaluate can hinder collaboration and delay meaningful progress. Through engaging agencies earlier, sharing leading practices, and identifying potential risks before they escalate into significant operational challenges, oversight organizations can take a proactive approach to strengthening government performance. Building collaboration with agencies can be done while preserving independence; rather, it can strengthen oversight initiatives by encouraging agencies to address challenges before they grow larger.
Strengthening oversight also requires better coordination across government. Participants highlighted the Joint Financial Management Improvement Program (JFMIP) as an example of a collaborative structure to advance shared priorities. Many called for better education for political appointees, congressional staff, and agency leadership on the roles of GAO and IGs. Better alignment across oversight priorities can also help gain traction on recommendations. For example, participants discussed prioritizing agency actions on key programs from GAO’s High-Risk List; this biennial GAO program, issued at the beginning of each new Congress, might also shape priorities of the future administrations to create greater momentum on implementation. Data sharing also presents an opportunity for improved coordination. Participants advocated for greater involvement from Chief Data Officers and Chief Information Officers, who can help advance data access and interoperability and work with General Counsel offices to address any legal issues.
Technology and AI
Artificial intelligence (AI) presents a significant opportunity to modernize oversight, but successful adoption of AI tools requires durable governance structures, data readiness, and workforce alignment. AI can transform the way oversight organizations conduct audits, identify potential fraud, and evaluate program performance. GAO has taken a use-case-driven, human-led approach to AI adoption. Examples include using an internal large language model (LLM) to identify legislation relevant to GAO’s work, create concise “Fast Facts” summaries and targeted briefings, and strengthen data analytics capabilities. AI enables expanded analytical capabilities of oversight organizations by identifying patterns and relationships across agencies or programs that may otherwise be difficult to detect. This technology can help auditors develop better insights, identify emerging risks, and make more informed recommendations.
Quality interoperable data is foundational to effective AI implementation. PIA demonstrated this through a use case involving the analysis of nearly 300,000 oversight reports and recommendations. Through this effort, the organization identified the importance of ensuring that AI-generated findings include citations and verifiable sources to mitigate the risk of hallucinations and support the reliability of results. Participants also recommended standardizing oversight report formats and data definitions so information can be more easily analyzed and shared across organizations.
Participants advocated for a “Human in the Lead” approach to AI adoption in the oversight community. This strategy can help knowledgeable professionals to retain responsibility for interpreting results, exercising judgment, and making any final decisions. To mitigate risks related to bias and accuracy, AI governance frameworks should establish clearly defined use cases, predetermine accountability for AI workflows, and provide necessary guidance on the use of AI tools. Oversight leadership should also strike a balance between automation and workforce development, investing in employee training and establishing employee standards for evaluating AI outputs. By taking an incremental approach, oversight organizations can build a sustainable AI adoption strategy while maintaining the necessary professional judgment and accountability essential to successful oversight.
Impact and Implementation
Oversight bodies should focus on improving government performance, strengthening public integrity, and delivering meaningful outcomes for the public. Closing the gap between oversight findings and agency action also requires a broader understanding of how oversight creates value. While demonstrating a return on investment (ROI) for individual recommendations may be difficult, tracking preventive activities (fraud awareness, suspensions, early interventions) can help capture the broader contributions of oversight. Improved agency performance and service delivery, reduced duplication, and increased public trust can demonstrate the impact of oversight beyond an individual recommendation.
Strengthening accountability for implementation can also drive how oversight translates into meaningful impact. The significant number of outstanding recommendations from oversight agencies represents a need for stronger mechanisms for agencies to act on recommendations. Participants discussed ways to reinforce accountability, including the GAO Priority Recommendation Letters addressed to agency heads and congressional oversight, such as hearings and appropriations, that can create clearer expectations for agencies to act on open recommendations. Ultimately, identifying problems reflects only one step; consistent follow-through can ensure that recommendations lead to tangible improvements.
In addition, the role of IGs can evolve to address the needs of modern oversight environments. IG offices often carry out both auditing and investigative responsibilities, and stronger coordination between these functions can help identify pain points and support implementation of solutions. Any structural reforms, including changes to the Inspector General Act, should preserve IG independence while strengthening coordination across oversight functions. Ultimately, the effectiveness of oversight should be measured by whether it helps government operate with greater accountability, integrity, and effectiveness.
Looking Ahead
Modern federal oversight challenges organizations to adapt to drive meaningful improvements in government performance. The roundtable insights demonstrated that by strengthening the relevance of oversight products, responsibly embracing emerging technologies, and translating findings into actionable improvements, oversight organizations can help build a more accountable government that delivers greater value to the public.